Last updated
Average Rent in Castleton & Rent Trends
Rent prices and market trends across 2 apartment communities in Castleton, Fishers, IN. Updated daily.
Market Average
$1,396/mo
▼ 5.4% from last month
Lowest Available
$1,252/mo
cheapest unit on market
Communities
2
tracked daily
Units Listed
13
available now
Castleton vs Fishers, IN Average
Castleton is cheaper the Fishers, IN average by $502/mo (26%). The citywide average is $1,898/mo across all neighborhoods.
Is Rent Going Up or Down in Castleton?
As of July 2026, the average rent in Castleton is $1,396 per month across 2 apartment communities and 13 available units. Rents have decreased $83 (5.4%) over the past month.
The most affordable option is Avery Point Apartments starting at $1,252/mo. By unit type, a 2-bedroom averages $1,396/mo.
Prices range from $1,252 to $1,475 per month. The most common price point is the $1,400 range, where 9 units are currently listed.
Castleton Rent Price History
Rent Price Distribution
Rent by Bedroom Type in Castleton
Rent Prices by Apartment in Castleton
| Property | Starting at | Average | Units | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Avery Point Apartments | $1,252/mo | $1,300/mo | 4 | 4.1 |
| The Preserve on Allisonville Townhomes | $1,315/mo | $1,439/mo | 9 | 3.3 |
Google Search Trends for Castleton Apartments
Search interest for apartments in this area over the past 12 months.
Search Interest Over Time
Frequently Asked Questions About Rent in Castleton
What is the average rent in Castleton?
Is rent going up or down in Castleton?
What is the cheapest apartment in Castleton?
How many apartments are available in Castleton?
What salary do I need to live comfortably in Castleton?
Built on the 25 to 30 percent rent-to-income guideline used by most landlords and credit-scoring models.
Minimum to afford average rent
$56,000/year
Based on the 30 percent rule, using our tracked average rent of $1,396/mo.
Comfortable income
$67,000/year
Based on the 25 percent rule, leaving more room for savings, transport, and groceries.
To afford the cheapest tracked apartment ($1,252/mo), you need to earn at least $50,000/year.
Median household income in Castleton is $128,141 , about 91% above the comfortable-living threshold.
Cost of living in Castleton
Overall prices in Castleton runs below the national average by about 5% (BEA Regional Price Parity index 94.7, where 100 equals the U.S. average). The breakdown below estimates monthly costs for a single adult, using national consumer-spending baselines from the Bureau of Labor Statistics scaled by Castleton's regional price parities.
| Category | Monthly estimate |
|---|---|
| Rent (market average) | $1,396 |
| Utilities | $374 |
| Groceries | $512 |
| Transportation | $892 |
| Healthcare | $435 |
| Other goods and services | $696 |
| Estimated total | $4,305/mo |
Population
100,918
Median household income
$128,141
Census median rent
$1,491/mo
Rent as % of income
25.9%
Median age
37.2
Mean commute
26 min
Methodology
Rent data
Sourced directly from each tracked apartment community and refreshed every 24 hours. Every listed unit price on this page is real and listed today.
Cost of living
Estimates combine national consumer-spending baselines from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (Consumer Expenditure Survey) with the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis Regional Price Parities (MARPP dataset). Both are peer-reviewed federal data releases published annually.
Salary to live comfortably
Applies the standard 25 to 30 percent rent-to-income rule on top of the listed rent. This is the same affordability guideline used by most landlords and credit-scoring models.
Demographic figures
Median household income, population, median age, commute time, Census median rent, and rent as percentage of income come from the U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey 5-year estimates, the most recent complete release.
Cost of living and demographic figures were last published in 2023.
Explore Castleton Apartments
Browse all 2 communities with daily-updated pricing and availability.