Rent Watch in Island Park, NY

See what changed, what stayed level, and what fits your budget. Prices update after successful checks.

Latest included check: Oct 1, 2026, 11:24 AM UTC

Limited recent comparisons

0 matched listings across 0 buildings. 19 current listings match your area, bedroom, and budget filters. Comparison window: 7 days.

Cuts

0

Increases

0

Unchanged

0

We need more recent comparisons to describe a city trend. A missing comparison does not mean the rent stayed unchanged.

PeriodPast 7 daysPast 30 days NeighborhoodAll neighborhoodsIsland Park 11558 BedroomsAll bedroomsStudio1 bedroom2 bedrooms3 bedrooms4 bedrooms5 bedrooms Maximum rent ($/mo) Minimum change ($/mo) Minimum change (%) Sort byLocal significanceDollar changePercentage changeLatest checkLowest current rent Apply filters

Largest listed rent cuts · 0 buildings

No confirmed changes match these filters. We do not infer stable rents from missing comparisons.

Browse current options

Current asking rents by bedroom count

• 1 bedroom · median listed rent

  $4,587.50/mo

• 2 bedrooms · median listed rent

  $5,105/mo

• 3 bedrooms · median listed rent

  $5,320/mo

See all current apartments in Island Park, NY

Recently observed listings

First observed in the past seven days. This date does not establish when the apartment became available.

• Avalon Harbor Isle · Unit 4 · $4,455/mo

  First observed Oct 1, 2026, 11:24 AM UTC

• Avalon Harbor Isle · Unit 13 · $5,320/mo

  First observed Sep 29, 2026, 10:08 PM UTC

• Avalon Harbor Isle · Unit 18 · $5,810/mo

  First observed Sep 29, 2026, 10:08 PM UTC

• Avalon Harbor Isle · Unit 19 · $5,815/mo

  First observed Sep 29, 2026, 10:08 PM UTC

• Avalon Harbor Isle · Unit 20 · $6,165/mo

  First observed Sep 29, 2026, 10:08 PM UTC

We compare the same identified apartment within one listing period. Asking prices, fees, and promotional effective prices can differ. Large events need repeat checks before we publish a story. Our sample covers the listings shown here.