How much does it cost to rent at Butler Plaza LLC?

Rent at Butler Plaza LLC in Madison, WI ranges from $1,525 to $2,625 per month as of September 1, 2026.

What is the average studio rent at Butler Plaza LLC?

The average studio apartment at Butler Plaza LLC costs $1,525/month, starting from $1,525.

What is the average 1 bed rent at Butler Plaza LLC?

The average 1 bed apartment at Butler Plaza LLC costs $1,606/month, starting from $1,550.

What is the average 2 bed rent at Butler Plaza LLC?

The average 2 bed apartment at Butler Plaza LLC costs $2,309/month, starting from $1,525.

Is Butler Plaza LLC a good apartment complex?

Butler Plaza LLC has a 4.2-star rating on Google based on 92 reviews.

Updated today at 8:21 p.m. CT

Butler Plaza LLC

21 N Butler St, Madison, WI 53703, USA

4.2 (92 reviews) Official Website

Live pricing, refreshed today at 8:21 p.m. CT

Units Listed

$1,525

Starting at

$1,974

Average

$2,625

Highest

$2.74

Per Sq Ft

PRO

Avg Days Listed

How does this compare? View Tenney-Lapham rent trends

Beds

Pricing by Bedroom

Studio

$1,525

from $1,525 · 1 units

~450 sqft avg

1 Bed

$1,606

from $1,550 · 7 units

~539 sqft avg

2 Bed

$2,309

from $1,525 · 9 units

~890 sqft avg

Rent Distribution

Price by Bedroom

Price Breakdown

Rent by Unit

Price vs. Square Footage

Price History

Timeframe

Property Price Trend

Units with Price Changes (17)

Largest 8 movers of 17

Last 15 days

Estimated Building Revenue

How is this calculated?

Rental revenue model

We follow each unit's listing activity at this building every day. When a unit stops being listed, we assume it leased at its last listed rent, adjusted for any advertised move-in special. Revenue is the sum of those assumed lease rents across the building's occupied units.

Building size: modeled from how many distinct units we have observed over time
Occupancy: building size minus currently listed units
Rents: observed lease-offs first, current asking rents as fallback

These are research estimates, not financial statements from the operator. Confidence: moderate (building size is modeled).

Est. Monthly Revenue

$1,655

$20K annual run rate

Modeled estimate

Est. Occupancy

of about 18 units (modeled from leasing activity)

Effective Rent on New Leases

$1,655

vs $1,974 current asking ($319 negotiation gap)

Recent Lease Activity

18 units tracked; 1 assumed leased, 17 listed now

See which units leased, when they left the market, and the rent they leased at.

Unlock with Pro

Property Intelligence

How is this calculated?

Negotiation Leverage Score (0-100)

Based on 5 observable signals from the property's listing data:

+30 pts: 15+ units currently listed
+25 pts: Active move-in specials
+20 pts: Deep discounts (>$150/mo off)
+15 pts: 5+ distinct floor plans
+10 pts: 25+ units listed

All signals come directly from the property's own listings. Occupancy and building size appear only in the Estimated Building Revenue section, and only when the building size is stated by the property or our unit-level observation history is deep enough to model it.

Listed Units

Good availability

0 floor plans

Move-in Specials

No active promotions

Negotiation Leverage

Moderate leverage

Some signals suggest room to negotiate, especially if you can be flexible on move-in date.

Price vs. Tenney-Lapham

Neighborhood

43 North Apartments

$700 McBride Companies LLC

$795 Lark at Kohl

$1,199 Capitol Centre Court Apartments

$1,215 The Rive Madison

$1,299 Hub On Campus Madison

$1,299 SEVEN27 at The Yards

$1,505

Butler Plaza LLC

$1,525

Quarter Row at The Yards

$1,650 The Continental

$1,700 ONE 09

$1,775

Comparing 11 apartments in Tenney-Lapham. Click any bar to view that building.

See Tenney-Lapham rent trends on the Madison, WI map Explore Madison, WI on the interactive map

Available Units

Sort

17 units

2 Bed

$1,525/mo

405 ft² · $3.77/ft² · #1

Down $70 since Sep 2 (was $1,595)

Studio

$1,525/mo

450 ft² · $3.39/ft² · #12

Down $25 since Sep 2 (was $1,550)

1 Bed

$1,550/mo

450 ft² · $3.44/ft² · #14

Down $745 since Sep 2 (was $2,295)

1 Bed

$1,550/mo

405 ft² · $3.83/ft² · #4

Down $975 since Sep 2 (was $2,525)

1 Bed

$1,595/mo

405 ft² · $3.94/ft² · #3

Down $800 since Sep 2 (was $2,395)

1 Bed

$1,595/mo

615 ft² · $2.59/ft² · #7

Down $1,030 since Sep 2 (was $2,625)

1 Bed

$1,625/mo

650 ft² · $2.50/ft² · #13

Down $725 since Sep 2 (was $2,350)

1 Bed

$1,655/mo

650 ft² · $2.55/ft² · #17

Down $640 since Sep 2 (was $2,295)

1 Bed

$1,675/mo

600 ft² · $2.79/ft² · #10

Up $150 since Sep 2 (was $1,525)

2 Bed

$2,195/mo

800 ft² · $2.74/ft² · #11

Up $570 since Sep 2 (was $1,625)

Unit	Floor Plan	Bed/Bath	Sqft	↑ Price	$/Sqft	Available	Listed	Details
1	--	2bd / --ba	405	$1,525	$3.77	--	Pro	Down $70 since Sep 2
12	--	Studio / --ba	450	$1,525	$3.39	--	Pro	Down $25 since Sep 2
14	--	1bd / --ba	450	$1,550	$3.44	--	Pro	Down $745 since Sep 2
4	--	1bd / --ba	405	$1,550	$3.83	--	Pro	Down $975 since Sep 2
3	--	1bd / --ba	405	$1,595	$3.94	--	Pro	Down $800 since Sep 2
7	--	1bd / --ba	615	$1,595	$2.59	--	Pro	Down $1,030 since Sep 2
13	--	1bd / --ba	650	$1,625	$2.50	--	Pro	Down $725 since Sep 2
17	--	1bd / --ba	650	$1,655	$2.55	--	Pro	Down $640 since Sep 2
10	--	1bd / --ba	600	$1,675	$2.79	--	Pro	Up $150 since Sep 2
11	--	2bd / --ba	800	$2,195	$2.74	--	Pro	Up $570 since Sep 2
8	--	2bd / --ba	800	$2,250	$2.81	--	Pro	Up $575 since Sep 2
16	--	2bd / --ba	800	$2,295	$2.87	--	Pro	Down $55 since Sep 2
15	--	2bd / --ba	1,200	$2,350	$1.96	--	Pro	Up $695 since Sep 2
5	--	2bd / --ba	1,200	$2,395	$2.00	--	Pro	Up $800 since Sep 2
6	--	2bd / --ba	1,200	$2,525	$2.10	--	Pro	Up $275 since Sep 2
2	--	2bd / --ba	405	$2,625	$6.48	--	Pro	Up $1,075 since Sep 2
9	--	2bd / --ba	1,200	$2,625	$2.19	--	Pro	Up $430 since Sep 2

Train activity

Trains close by

Freight line 1,596 ft away · 6 trains/day

3 daytime, 3 overnight
No road crossing within earshot. Horns unlikely.
Operator: WSOR

Why this matters →

City Club

Resident Notes & Access Codes

Real tips from people who lived at this property: what leasing and daily living are actually like, plus the gate, parking, and entry codes you only learn once you move in. See all Madison, WI notes

No resident notes for this property yet.